I did this backwards, as I purchased Ravenhearst first and then worked my way backwards through the Mystery Case Files. For better or worse, this one is my favorite.
I loved the storyline and the whole otherworldly atmosphere of the game. The hand-drawn puzzles were beautiful and in keeping with the mood. The door puzzles were challenging,but not overly frustrating, and a lot of fun.
The game was visually stunning and the music and eerie voice urging me on were perfect accompaniments to an already engrossing experience.
If you like searching games and appreciate a good puzzle wrapped in a mystery, this is the game for you.
I can't wait for the next installment!